Approaches to Managing Online Discussions

For classes that involve any degree of participation, it is important to consider how to manage online discussions. This article explores the options and considerations involved in student participation within online classes. 

Extent of discussion moderation

For subjective material common within the social sciences, discussion is one of the most effective learning environments. This is maybe especially so in more advanced classes, where engaging directly with the material enables deeper consideration of the material. 

Free-flowing discussion

Just as in-person, free-flowing discussion between students maybe one of the most engaging forms of discussion. In this environment, the instructor is able to step back from the active discussion, allowing students to discuss among themselves the material, with limited oversight to ensure that the discussion remains focused.

Although free-flowing discussion can work well with small groups, at around 15 or 20 students, the ability to achieve a naturally flowing conversation starts to break down, with the key challenge for students in knowing when to speak, and the challenge of multiple students starting to talk at the same time. Another challenge with free-flowing discussion, and maybe especially so as the class size increases, is where a limited number of eager students begin to dominate discussion, leaving other students feeling that they are not able to feel as though they are able to participate (or the that the only way to do so is to interrupt others).

Mediated discussion

A slight adaptation to free-flowing discussion, more suited to larger groups, is to mediate the discussion through the instructor calling on individuals. This can both avoid the possibility that individuals ‘clash’ when speaking, interruptions of others are avoided, and that attention can be made to ensure that students who would not otherwise talk are brought into the conversation. 

Directed discussion

While both free-flowing and mediated discussions put the instructor in a relatively passive role, it is also possible to take a more active role in the discussion, giving a greater influence in shaping the discussion. This may be particularly important in ensuring that conversation is directed in different or specific directions, and avoid repetition of perspectives or the conversation to stay at a relatively surface level without assumptions being challenged. 

Norms regarding maintaining microphones on / off

A consideration related to the form of conversation is whether to encourage students to leave their microphones on throughout the class, or to only turn them on when they directly want to speak. While encouraging students to leave their microphone may help with free-flowing discussion, one of the dangers of this approach is that the slight background noise from a non-speaking participant (who has their microphone on), can disrupt the class, both causing noise and the focus of the video feed to switch to them. As such, in general, an ‘all-on’ microphone policy is best suited to situations when the number of students in the class is particularly low. 

While in general, it is not advisable for all students to have their microphones on throughout the class, the clear exception to this is for the instructor, where in general the ability to speak without having to first turn on the microphone overrides the disadvantages (with it important that instructors are located in a quiet environment for the successful delivery of the material).

Physically or digitally raising hands

Another consideration, particularly important with either mediated/directed needed is how students should identify if they have a question or response: either by raising their hands or using the blue ‘hands raise’ icon within Zoom.

Advantages of physical hand raising over digital hands

  • Avoiding having digital hands left up: One issue with using digital hands is a tendency for students to leave the icon on after the conversation has moved on or their point has already been raised. This can thus result in a slightly more disjointed discussion, with students being called on that no longer have points to raise.
  • More natural discussion: Raising hands physically in many ways feels more natural and consistent with the in-person experience vs. using a digital button.  

Advantages of raising over digital hands​ over physical hands

  • Students are elevated to the top of the gallery view: One of the key advantages of using digital hand-raising is that it elevates that student’s position within the gallery view. This can be particularly useful when there are more students than fit on the gallery view (25 by default, or up to 49 with a change to default settings), avoiding the need to regularly click to see additional students, or potentially missing students that are not on the first page of students.
  • Reduces the potential of missing students: One challenge with looking for physical hands being raised is the possibility of missing a student that has their hands raised – in part because the blue hand is quite contrasting, it is harder to miss. 

Summary

Discussions can be an important part of online classes, providing opportunities for students to engage more directly with class content than a lecture format. Successful management of online discussions is however not easy, and maybe particularly so in larger classes. While consideration of the best way to approach the discussions can help achieve a natural flowing environment, as with all approaches, it is important to be willing to mix it up, and if one approach is not working to try a different way of integrating discussion into your class. 

Related articles

5 Features We Hope Zoom Adds Soon

Zoom has quickly become the go-to video conferencing software for online learning. But it is far from perfect, and some much-needed features would make the online learning experience a much more satisfying experience, for students and educators alike. Here is our wish list for features we would love Zoom to have.

Managing Virtual Office Hours

Virtual office hours can be an important companion to an online course, allowing students to resolve administrative questions and address gaps in understanding. This article explores different approaches for holding virtual office hours.

Using Streamlabs OBS with Zoom

Streamlabs OBS is a great way to turbo-charge your Zoom calls, allowing you to display overlays on your content. This article outlines the easy approach to connect Streamlabs to OBS.

Preventing the Zoom Meeting Control Bar Auto Hiding

Although Zoom includes an easy to use options bar that appears at the bottom of the call, the standard behavior is for this bar to auto-hide. When presenting a Zoom class it is useful to have these options easily available so that they can be clicked as needed. This article illustrates how the change this default behavior.

Personalizing Zoom

Although Zoom does not allow many opportunities for customization, there are several small adjustments to make Zoom slightly more personalized. This article will explain changing your profile picture, waiting room interface, and other personalization opportunities.

Hide the Zoom Control Bar When Screen Sharing

The Zoom control bar is normally useful to have at hand (and for teaching it can be useful to always have it displayed). However, if you are sharing your entire screen it can be useful to disable it so that viewers can see your entire screen.

Disable Zoom Chat

The chat feature on Zoom can sometimes be useful – potentially for sharing links with others – but it can also be distracting when presenting. Getting a flashing notification can interrupt the flow of a presentation, and allowing others to share messages when you are presenting can lead to side-conservations. Learn how to temporarily and permanently disable the chat feature. 

Using Teaching Assistants in Online Classes

For large online classes, in-person teaching assistants can be a useful resource can to resolve in-class issues and improve the flow of the class. This article examines possible uses of Teaching Assistants in the online format, as well as how to set up Zoom so that they can take on these responsibilities.

Related articles

Bringing Energy to your Online Class

One of the most important considerations when teaching online is how to maintain student energy and engagement. This article explores ways of bringing some energy to the class, with a specific focus on online teaching environments.

Read More »

Display 49 Participants in Zoom Gallery View

Although the default settings in Zoom limits the number of thumbnails displayed in the gallery view to 25, this can be increased to 49. This article explains how to increase the number of participants displayed and the technical requirements to do.

Read More »

Contingency Planning your Online Classes

Online teaching presents some new difficulties that have the potential of derailing a class. This article explores some possible sources of disruption and considers ways of reducing the likelihood of issues arising, or dealing with such problems should they occur in the class.

Read More »

Setting up a Class in Zoom

If you are new to Zoom, there are a lot of settings that are useful of being aware of when setting up a meeting. This article explores those settings, with guidance on what may be useful for your class.

Read More »

Sharing a PowerPoint via Zoom

One of the most common ways of presenting on Zoom is to share a PowerPoint Presentation. In this article, we will explore how to set PowerPoint presentations to open as a separate Windows that can then be shared from within Zoom.

Read More »

Establishing Online Class Norms

Establishing clear norms and expectations around online learning is important for ensuring a smooth and successful class delivery. This article explores some of the important expectations to establish to help deliver a smooth and successful class.

Read More »

Downloading Class Attendance from Zoom

If your class incorporates attendance as part of its grading structure, it is useful to be able to download a list of class attendance, rather than have to manually record participation levels – this article describes how to download attendance for each class.

Read More »

Resolving Student Technical Issues with Zoom

From connection and internet issues to microphone and webcam problems, there will inevitably be at least some technology issues during your Zoom classes. This article and its accompanying student-companion, is intended to help you to provide support to students who are having issues connecting to your Zoom call.

Read More »

To Sit or to Stand when Teaching Online

It’s easy to assume that sitting is the best way of teaching on-line – all your students will be sitting down. However, there are some advantages to consider of standing up when delivering your class. This article will explore the benefits of both options.

Read More »

See a Student View of Zoom

It can be useful to see Zoom as your students do – this makes it easier to know what they are likely seeing at there end and provide guidance and instructions. This article shows how Zooms looks from the student perspective.

Read More »